Responses to Questions from the Board's Meeting with Student Leaders

Below are memoranda forwarded on behalf of the superintendent of schools regarding questions submitted by students at the Board of Education's recent meeting with student leaders.

The questions discuss: Portable Communication Devices, bullying, ESOL, Middle School Reform, and school lunch prices.

11.04.06 Port Comm Dev

11.04.06 Bullying Question

11.04.06 ESOL Program Question

11.04.06 MS Reform Plans

11.04.06 School Lunch Prices

Gazette: SMOB Voting Rights

Student board member voting bill running short on time

Measure running into Senate opposition again

by Alan Brody | Staff Writer

ANNAPOLIS — Legislation that would grant full voting rights to the student member of the Montgomery County Board of Education passed the House of Delegates on Monday afternoon, but still faces resistance in the Senate.

 

The county's Senate delegation was considering taking up the bill Monday night, after The Gazette newsletter's deadline.

 

Several student government leaders appealed to the Senate delegation last week to pass the bill so it can be considered by the full chamber, but a vote on the measure was delayed. The House vote in favor of the measure was 92-39.

 

Student advocates have lobbied state lawmakers for two years to grant the student member of the board, who is elected to a one-year term by county middle and high school students, the right to vote on collective bargaining, budget actions, school closings and boundary decisions. Currently, they can register an opinion on those issues, but it does not count toward the overall vote.

 

Under the proposal, the student member would still be barred from weighing in on disciplinary matters involving teachers.

 

Montgomery County delegates overwhelmingly approved the legislation in early February, but several senators are hesitant to allow students the same voting privileges as members elected by countywide voters.

 

"These are great kids and they're really sincere and really competent, but this is undemocratic," said state Sen. Brian E. Frosh (D-Dist. 16) of Bethesda.

 

The student member is largely elected by nonvoting residents who do not pay county taxes and therefore do not have the same perspective as adult members, he said. Students also should not have to endure contentious debates on redistricting that can even be difficult for adult members, Frosh added.

 

"The hardest part of our job here is to say no and you don't learn that before you graduate high school," he explained.

 

State Sen. Jennie M. Forehand (D-Dist. 17) of Rockville also is uncomfortable granting student members full voting rights, but said she would be amenable to extending their privileges to one or two categories.

 

The current student school board member, Alan Xie, a junior at Richard Montgomery High School, told senators last week that it's important for the student representative to have voting rights on all board decisions because they directly impact the student body.

 

"The presence of an informed and franchised student member strengthens board decisions," echoed Michael Hagan, a Damascus High School senior who is president of the Maryland Association of Student Councils, the statewide student government association.

 

Anne Arundel County is the only jurisdiction in Maryland that grants full voting rights to its student school board member. Several other counties allow partial voting rights.

 

Staff writer Margie Hyslop contributed to this report.

 

abrody@gazette.net

SMOB Voting Rights Passes the House!

On March 26th, the House voted to pass HB 539 by a vote of 92 to 39. Congratulations to everyone who's worked so hard to lobby for this bill, and thanks so much to all of the Delegates who voted in favor of passing it! You are truly doing a service to the educational system in Montgomery County.

Now, we are waiting on Senate action. The bill underwent First Reading in the Education, Health, and Environmental Affairs Committee on March 25th, and a hearing has been scheduled for Tuesday, April 5th at 1 PM.

The hearing will be located at 2 West Miller Senate Building, 11 Bladen Street, Annapolis, MD 21401-1991.  See this list for the complete schedule; it's important to note that the bills are listed may not be the order in which they're heard. Anyone wishing to testify should arrive in Annapolis and sign the witness register by 12 PM Noon. If you have written testimony, please submit 25 copies to committee staff by 12 PM Noon for distribution prior to the hearing. After 12 PM Noon, please submit testimony at the time that you testify. The Committee will receive testimony from its sponsors (Delegates Kaiser and Hucker), department, and limited proponents and opponents.

Please show up to provide support for the bill or deliver testimony!

Valerie Ervin on the Kojo Nnamdi Show

Check out County Council President Valerie Ervin on the Kojo Nnamdi Show (88.5 FM). She's also a former Board of Education member.

Superintendent Search - Leadership Profile Report

For everyone who hasn't seen it, here's the Leadership Profile Report from HYA about the Superintendent Search. Stay tuned for more info!

This 21-page document summarizes public input about the search, with data disaggregated by stakeholder.

Superintendent Search Feedback

Potential Budget Reductions

Below is Dr. Weast's Revised Summary of Potential Budget Reductions.

Staffing Allocation March 4, 2011

Bethesda Magazine Interview with Dr. Weast

The Last Lessons of Jerry Weast

A question and answer session with the retiring superintendent of Montgomery County Public School.

BY CARIN DESSAUER

Photo credit: Michael Ventura

Jerry Weast knew he was facing a challenge when he left his position as superintendent of the Guilford County, N.C., system in 1999 to become superintendent of Montgomery County Public Schools. Yes, Montgomery County schools were good, but the area’s demographics had been changing dramatically. More than 20 percent of the county’s children qualified for free or reduced-price lunches and demonstrated special instructional needs—a number that had doubled in two decades. And there was pressure to close an achievement gap between the diverse populations.

Weast, 63, who will retire at the end of this academic year, has been credited with not only closing that gap, but with doing much more—sometimes generating controversy along the way. He has overseen the state’s largest school district, and the nation’s 16th largest, with 144,000 students in 200 schools employing 22,000 people. While so doing, the Rockville resident has raised academic standards, racked up some impressive achievements and nearly doubled the county’s education budget, which currently is more than $2.1 billion.

Sitting in his office surrounded by memorabilia—including the school bell that his mother rang in a one-room Kansas schoolhouse in the 1930s—Weast says he is ever-conscious that “where you come from” shouldn’t be an impediment to getting a good education.

Q&A

How did you end up in education?

I was a business major and was planning to go into the business world. But I got the chance to coach a Little League football team and I really enjoyed it. I got to thinking that accounting is good, but working with kids is better. [So] from 1969 to 1972 I was an accounting and psychology teacher in Belleville and Colony, Kansas.

My dad was a farmer, and I learned a tremendous amount from him that has been integral to my success in education. What he taught me was how to observe, the importance of building relationships and how to be respectful of people, regardless of the position they hold or the degree that they have. Status and titles never impressed my father—making a difference is what mattered to him.

What has been your proudest moment as Montgomery County Schools superintendent?

One thing we really showed for America, not just for Maryland, is that if you do reform right, you actually can improve the statistics that everybody worships in America—but also improve the ethos of the school system.

This system is as large as it’s ever been in its history, it is as diverse as it’s ever been in its history and it’s gone from a majority-white system to a majority-minority system in the last decade. It went from 6 percent poverty not that many years back to well over 46,000 kids in poverty, which are more students than you have in the Washington, D.C., school system.

For 35 years, we have been keeping track of the SAT scores for this system, and last year’s graduating class set the highest record with the most diverse class, the most kids in poverty and the most kids that do not speak English [as a first language]. We went from 7,000 tests for Advanced Placement [when I started] to 30,000 tests. The International Baccalaureate program grew from 500 to 9,500 kids, and the largest concentration of the program in the world [is] here in this system.

Our teacher retention rate improved. Our graduation rate: Out of the entire top 50 [school] systems in the country in size, we were No. 1 not once but twice in a row the last two years. We were a finalist for [several educational awards]. …Newsweek puts us in the top 3 percent of the high schools in the nation on getting kids college-ready. And we had more high schools in Newsweek’s Top 100 “Best High Schools” ranking than any other school system in America.

We have one of the best systems of teacher evaluations through peer review, the least acrimony amongst the unions and the schools. …I could go on and on.

One thing you have to get across: It isn’t me. It is the employees, the community and the kids here working together. What I have done is maybe provided some structures, built relationships, provided a more diffused leadership program, given them some shared ownership along with the responsibility and developed the rubrics and curriculum that align with college-ready and career-ready.

Along the way, you’ve had a challenging relationship with the Parents’ Coalition, the network of citizen activists who use the political process and other means to hold MCPS accountable.

The thing people accuse me of is listening, but not hearing. I hear, but I do not always agree. I am sorry that the world is faster than it was 10 years ago. I did not do that. [But] if we do not keep up, then our kids will be behind. We have to stop whining and get real.

What are the remaining problems?

My most pressing problem now is that we have grown by 6,300 kids—a whole cluster [a high school, with middle and elementary schools] in the last 36 months—and we do not have the buildings to support that. We cannot keep up with the growth. It takes six or seven years to get a building through, so we are definitely going to be short on buildings.

[People] are not coming here because of the good roads or the cheap taxes or the cheap houses. They are coming here for the schools. …And the state is $160 million behind in what they said they would get us.

My next biggest problem: You cannot measure kids with a bunch of standardized tests. If you increase the testing, it does not mean that you will increase the quality. The quality is about teaching kids to be creative. 

Last year’s documentary Waiting for Superman looked at the nation’s failing public school system. Do you think it reflects reality?

When I was going through school, there was the risk of the Communist threat. When going through college, it was the Soviet threat. Later years, it was that the nation was at risk, then “No Child Left Behind,” now the “Race to the Top.” [But what it is really about is the] same thing as when my mother was a teacher: preparing the kids for the future.

Many parents say that Montgomery County schools are great for overachievers, but not so great for average students.

That is one reason we created the Seven Keys to College Readiness. What we have shown is that more kids can handle the more rigorous trajectory than what we thought.

What are the challenges given the diversity of, say, Whitman, Wootton, Kennedy and Einstein high schools, and how do you address these both pragmatically and in terms of the budget?

Diversity is one of the best things that has happened. We have embraced it. Use common sense: Some kids need more time; some need smaller classrooms. Give it to them. Differentiate the delivery. …But do not compromise on the rigor.

There is concern that we are rushing our children to learn math and that one reason that children in Asian countries are much stronger in math is that they drum in the basics before moving to the next levels. What are your thoughts?

I agree that the math has to be changed. Having been to Asia, [I have seen that] they are trying to get our creativity; we are trying to get their depth. Both of us have half of the equation.

Who should succeed you?

Somebody who is as passionate, persistent, who values the employees, who loves kids, who looks to the future and understands that you are dealing with human beings, each one of them unique. …[Someone who is able to deal with the fact that this is] one of the most politically charged systems under the Capitol dome. Someone [who] has to want to live in a fishbowl and be able to handle it.

What list of priorities would you give your successor?

[Keep this improvement] rolling; expand early-childhood education; keep working on teacher quality; improve the curriculum; find more ways to engage our community, especially our community that does not speak English; make school more fun for the kids and the teachers, and that means more tools, more technology and more engagement; take the art, music and P.E., things kids enjoy, and integrate them with the curriculum; and do whatever it takes. …Don’t be afraid. Try to remember to bless your enemies because they help you understand that there are different points of view.

What’s next for you?

I do not want to give up the energy and enthusiasm for education. …[I want to] try a foundation or nonprofit. …I have six grandchildren. I want to see them. …[And] I want to stay [in the area]. I really love the people here and love the excitement and energy of this area. People here really want to do better, and they are driven by that.

Jerry Weast lists the top 10 accomplishments of his tenure*

1. MCPS has the highest graduation rate among the nation’s largest school districts, according to Education Week.
2. Nearly 30,000 Advanced Placement exams were taken in 2010, more than three times the number of exams taken in 1999.
3. The class of 2010 scored an average of 1,653 on the SAT, an all-time high and well above the state and national averages.
4. More than 90 percent of kindergartners last year met or exceeded reading targets, narrowing the achievement gap by race, ethnicity and socioeconomic status.
5. Last year’s graduates earned $234 million in college scholarships, an immediate 10 percent return on the MCPS budget.
6. A collaborative relationship with our staff, which includes having our employee associations at the budget table. Over the past three years, the associations that represent more than 20,000 employees have helped us cut more than $300 million from the budget and have voted to forgo cost-of-living increases for the past two years.
7. An increased focus on early education, including the expansion of prekindergarten programs for our neediest students.
8. A focus on parent and community outreach to all the citizens of Montgomery County at the district and school level.
9. High levels of employee satisfaction. In 2009, MCPS had a teacher retention rate of nearly 95 percent, much higher than other large districts around the country.
10. Our organizational excellence has been recognized recently with two prestigious national awards. In October, MCPS was named a finalist for the 2010 Broad Prize for Urban Education, which recognizes large school districts that have raised student performance while narrowing the achievement gap. MCPS is the first school district in the Washington area to be chosen as a finalist. And in November, MCPS was a recipient of the 2010 Malcolm Baldrige National Quality Award, which recognizes institutions that improve student outcomes, engage and empower staff and the community, carefully allocate resources and demonstrate leadership and social responsibility. MCPS is just the sixth school district to be an award recipient.

* in no particular order

What others say about Jerry Weast

Jay Mathews, Washington Post education columnist and blogger: “Jerry Weast was one of the most energetic and effective school superintendents I ever encountered. He is certainly in the Top 10 nationally in terms of raising the achievement of low-income students, which to me is the most important measure of an educator. The only reason I would not make him No. 1 is that he has not yet taken on one of our distressed urban districts, but if he did so, I think he would be very good.

“There was an advantage for him in running a district with voters, parents and school board members as smart and as generous as those in Montgomery County, but there are other similarly affluent districts that have not seen such gains for their most disadvantaged students.

“He was a good politician, a good publicist (he would come all the way to my office in Alexandria to explain his latest program) and a very good analyst of what worked and what didn’t with kids. I hope he writes a long book explaining it all in his characteristic clear and vivid way.”

Michelle Rhee, former D.C public schools chancellor: “Jerry Weast took the Montgomery County schools to a new level. His work and leadership made MCPS a model for the nation.”

Rosanne Hurwitz, activist with the Parents’ Coalition of Montgomery County: “My kids got a great education, but there was a lot of work to advocate on their behalf. The system is designed for the great middle. If you are at the ultra-top or ultra-bottom, then the school system does not care. …I would hope that the next superintendent is more open to all parents and meets their needs.”

Valerie Ervin, Montgomery County Council president, Education Committee chair and former Board of Education member: “At the end of the day, he was a masterful politician who had the right idea at the right time. I think for the most part our students have benefited.

“…But one could say that the achievement gap is as big as it has ever been. Montgomery College has said that students coming from Montgomery County have to be remediated in math and reading. So even though the story that we were told was a hopeful one of great success for individual students, there is still a persistent achievement gap in Montgomery County Public Schools. …He is leaving at the right time because we now need some fresh ideas from a new visionary leader who can take us to the next level.”

George Leventhal, Montgomery County Council member: “Jerry Weast has accomplished a great deal, and he put an appropriate focus on outcome disparities between the kids from more fortunate families versus kids from less fortunate families. …He was a very successful superintendent during the time of rising revenues, but I think he is less well equipped to deal with a climate of shrinking revenues. [And] I think that he is too involved in political campaigns. I do not think that is the role of a superintendent.”

Potomac writer Carin Dessauer, a former executive with CNN and CNN.com, is a regular contributor to Bethesda Magazine.

Funding Our Children’s Future: The Right Thing to Do

Funding Our Children’s Future: The Right Thing to Do
February 18, 2011

Dear Friend of Montgomery County Public Schools:

On February 14, 2011, the Montgomery County Board of Education approved a $2.2 billion FY 2012 operating budget request for Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS). Mindful of the economic climate, the Board adopted the minimum funding level mandated under the state’s Maintenance of Effort (MOE) law, which requires counties to fund education at the same per student level each year. In order for Montgomery County to meet MOE, it must increase local education funding by $82 million to address increased enrollment of more than 3,300 students. If the county fails to meet its minimum funding obligation under MOE, as a penalty, the school district may lose at least $22 million in additional state aid. The Board’s adopted budget request, which includes no new programs, will now be submitted to Montgomery County Executive Isiah Leggett and the Montgomery County Council for consideration.

As a Board, we have been careful fiscal stewards. When there were federal stimulus dollars available, we were able to assist our county in closing the deficit. In the last two years alone, we have worked hand-in-hand with the county to waive $250 million dollars owed to MCPS. Over the past three years, MCPS has saved more than $300 million through budget cuts and expenditure controls. This has resulted in the loss of hundreds of positions, drastic reductions in central administrative services, and an increase of class size by an average of one student. In fact, MCPS is now spending $1,000 less per student this year (FY 2011) than it did last year.

The superintendent has released a sobering list of non-recommended cuts that amount to approximately $50 million. The Board has not taken action on specific cuts, but it is likely that we will need to make reductions before this budget is finalized. The challenge would be to make reductions that are not so deep that they do lasting damage to our schools. If we have to take the non-recommended cuts as proposed by the superintendent, the effect on direct delivery of instruction will be devastating. Regardless, every student in every school across the county will be affected by the reductions that are coming. We have concerns about the ability of the central office to manage the school system with the cuts being proposed. Some officials believe we can continue to absorb cut after cut without affecting student outcomes. They are wrong. Increases to class size, and cuts to counselors, paraeducators, special education and other teachers, special programs, sports, after-school activities, and other staff and programs will have devastating impacts that will be difficult, if not impossible, to reverse.

The Board’s action on the budget followed the good news that Governor Martin O’Malley has recommended providing the school district with $37.2 million more in state aid than had been anticipated in the FY 2012 operating budget. These recommendations are needs-based and speak eloquently to how much Montgomery County has changed over the past decade; it is no longer the wealthy enclave that people think it is. The governor’s actions signal how much he appreciates the need to keep MCPS a top-functioning school system renowned for its commitment to academic success for all children. The Board thanks Governor O’Malley for standing by the children of Montgomery County at a time of great fiscal anxiety and exploding enrollment. Many more of the students coming to us are living in poverty and bring greater needs into the classroom than ever before.

Some County Council members have suggested that while they support the intent of the MOE law, its requirements should be relaxed in times of fiscal crisis. These suggestions come at a time when the federal stimulus dollars for public education have dried up and the state has signaled its intention to shift the cost of pensions to local school systems. The Board agrees that the MOE law should be amended—for different reasons. As currently written, if the County Council does not fund the school system at the maintenance of effort level, and a waiver is not granted, the penalty hits the schools’ budget directly, and penalizes our students twice. The Board intends to work with all the other school systems in Maryland to effect a change in this law in Annapolis. We salute our County Council and county executive for their past support of our school system. MCPS is a recipient of the 2010 Malcolm Baldrige National Quality Award and was a finalist for the Broad Prize for Urban Education because of our community’s tradition of demanding and funding excellence in education. We ask our leaders to simply obey the law and fund our budget at the minimum MOE floor level. It is the right thing to do.

Sincerely,

Christopher S. Barclay
President, Montgomery County Board of Education

For more information on the FY 2012 budget, visit our website.

SMOB Candidates

Today was the SMOB Nominating Convention, and there was a great turnout of middle and high school kids from all across the county. Several members of the Board of Education also provided comments.

The final two candidates for this year's SMOB election are Hal Zeitlin and me, and the election will take place on April 13th.

Check out each candidate's voter guide here: http://www.montgomeryschoolsmd.org/departments/studentaffairs/smob/candidates.shtm

Superintendent's Recommendation for Wheaton & Edison

Dr. Weast has recommended that Wheaton and Edison retain their separate identities, and that we identify program and budget efficiencies to help develop the unique programs at each school.

His specific suggestions regarding programs, the budget, and recruitment are below: